Is the Constitution Valid?

The question is; by what constitutional authority does the federal government control the private exchange between a person and their doctor, or the private contract between a person and their in state insurance company, or the the private contract between a doctor and the in state insurance company?

Discussed between a judge and some lawyers below.



So without torturing the constitution we clearly see that the congress doesn't have the authority to take over health care. Congress has limited and specifically delegated powers, the 8th and 10th amendments specifically state that powers beyond those specifically delegated to congress are reserved to the states and the people.

President Obama in a recent town hall meeting confirmed this. Where states that the problem with our constitution is that it doesn't allow the federal government to take "bold steps" in changing the US. Thank god for the constitution.



So the constitution says the government cant take over health care, Obama admits the constitution is a "problem" to taking over health care, so why are we the people allowing this to happen?